Going down, by Tim Shea

5 minutos a leer

por

There is a well-known American expression that captures the experience of being called back into a familiar social or professional setting. This phrase is “Been there, Done that.” I can personally relate to this saying, having experienced it – First in Ferrol and then repeated in Ourense. In both instances, I was brought in late in the season to take on the role of head coach in the ACB, with the aim of “saving” the team. Both experiences were regrettable and left a lasting impression on me

Relegation, a key aspect of the promotion and relegation system, was first introduced in Spanish football with the establishment of La Liga in 1929. Congratulations to Relegation on approaching its centennial milestone!

In contrast to soccer, which can end in a draw, nearly all other sports conclude with a definitive outcome: either a win or a loss. This is the reality. Additionally, some leagues, while crowning a champion at the end of the season, also remove a set number of teams based on their performance (wins and losses). I would like to share my personal interpretation of this historical phenomenon.

Relegation is a dreadful experience. It is harsh, cruel, and deeply unsettling. From the perspective of this relocated American, it feels fundamentally anti-sport. For a team or club facing relegation, the tension is palpable, almost tangible. The participants are on edge, playing not to win but to avoid losing. The anxiety is overwhelming, and the fear of failure looms large, akin to an insurmountable wall. Prestige, pride, finances, and honor are all at stake. A dark, foreboding cloud hangs over the team, the club, its supporters, and the entire city. Being at the top of the league feels like paradise, while being at the bottom is akin to hell. This relic from 1929 has outlived its usefulness and should be reconsidered. Professional sports have evolved into a mature industry. It should not be constrained by outdated ideas. Dinosaurs also faced extinction.

Here are the primary consequences of relegation for European sports clubs as it affects them both on and off the field.

1. Financial Impact

• Revenue Decline: Relegation typically results in a significant drop in revenue for clubs, mainly due to the loss of television rights income. Higher-tier leagues usually generate substantially more broadcasting revenue than their lower-tier counterparts.

• Matchday Income: Competing in a less competitive league often results in lower attendance, particularly for clubs that previously enjoyed a larger fanbase in the top division. This decline in attendance directly influences ticket sales, sponsorships, and merchandise sales.

• Sponsorship Agreements: Sponsors are likely to offer reduced deals to relegated clubs, as their visibility in a lower-tier league is less appealing.

2. Talent Drain

• Player Departures: Relegation frequently prompts key players to seek opportunities in higher leagues. Relegated clubs struggle to provide the same level of competition or salary.

• Changes in Management and Staff: Relegation often triggers managerial shifts. A club may hire a new manager experienced in lower divisions, or the current manager might depart. Staff changes can be extensive, affecting coaching teams and even medical staff.

• Recruitment Challenges: Attracting high-caliber players in a lower division becomes increasingly difficult. While some talented individuals may wish to remain and assist the club in regaining its top-tier status, many others will be reluctant to join a relegated team.

3. Effects on Club Identity and Reputation

• Diminished Prestige: Relegation reduces a club’s standing as a top-tier team, which can also harm its international reputation, making it more challenging to attract sponsors or elite talent in the future.

• Fan Sentiment: Following relegation, fans of historic clubs may experience disillusionment or frustration. This shift in sentiment can result in reduced support and attendance, which can further jeopardize the club’s financial health.

4. Psychological and Social Impact

• Team Morale: A drop to a lower division typically has a negative effect on team morale. Players may feel less motivated, which can lead to a decline in their performance levels.

• Community Impact: Clubs with strong local or regional ties significantly influence their communities. Relegation can damage local pride, potentially causing social unrest or diminishing community involvement.

5. Promotion Race and Pressure for Return

• Pressure to Return: Relegated clubs often face intense pressure to quickly regain their previous status. The financial repercussions of remaining in a lower league for an extended period can be severe, prompting clubs to restructure and enhance their squads for promotion. However, the competition to ascend back to the top tier is intense.

• Relegation/Promotion “Yo-Yo” Phenomenon: Some clubs find themselves in a cycle of repeated relegation and promotion, often referred to as a “yo-yo” effect, as they struggle to maintain consistency after being relegated but manage to secure promotion again within a season or two.

6. Strategic Changes

• Change in Playing Style: Teams that have been relegated frequently modify their tactical strategies. They may adopt a more defensive style and adjust to the physical demands and playing style of lower leagues, which often prioritize direct football over ball control.

• Youth Development: Relegation can prompt a shift in focus towards nurturing young talent or investing in more affordable options to stay competitive in the lower league.

7. Legal and Structural Consequences

• Legal and Contractual Issues: Following relegation, player contracts and salaries may be subject to renegotiation. Many high-profile players have relegation clauses in their contracts, allowing them to depart for lower transfer fees or even for free.

• Ownership and Governance: In severe cases, relegation can lead to changes in ownership or governance structures. with potential acquisitions by investors aiming to restore the club’s elite status.

8. Impact of European Competitions

• Absence from European Competitions: Relegation excludes the club from participating in European tournaments (such as the Champions League and Europa League), which can significantly affect both its financial standing and reputation, particularly if the club had been a consistent contender.

9. Long-Term Consequences for Club Structure

• Financial Pressure: A prolonged absence from the top league can impose considerable financial strain on the club. This may necessitate the sale of key assets, including players, and could even lead to financial instability or bankruptcy.

• Rebuilding Initiatives: Clubs in lower divisions frequently need to revamp their infrastructure, focusing on player development, facility upgrades, and marketing strategies to reclaim their position in the top tier.

In conclusion, relegation for European sports clubs represents more than just a competitive hurdle; it is a complex crisis that can impact financial stability, player and fan loyalty, and the club’s future prospects. I have achieved championship victories on two occasions and have also faced relegation challenges twice. I can confidently say that winning a championship is an incredible experience; while the relegation event is something you wouldn’t wish upon your worst enemies.

To be clear! The world of sports has evolved significantly since 1929, and it’s high time that sports federations adapt to these changes as well.